Writing "he should graduate from a good university and have five years of experience" does not reveal the success criteria of the vacancy. Competency-based selection pre-establishes the role's realistic task, evidence of that task, and a uniform scoring system for all. A degree and experience may remain necessary in some regulated positions; approach does not mean automatically canceling them.
Turn the role into a skill language
OECD skills-based labor market report examines the recognition of proof of skill alongside formal documentation. Ask the hiring manager for three realistic job results. For example, the result for a “CRM analyst” might be clean customer data, reliable reporting, and a decision note for the sales team. Then write the observed skill for each result: finding repetition, explaining the difference, making a decision recommendation.
Select the proof and the rubric at the same time
| Bacarıq | İş nümunəsi | 1 bal | 3 bal | 5 bal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Data quality | Small anonymous CRM table | He doesn't see the mistakes | Finds key repeats | Justifies the error, impact and correction |
| Qərar izahı | One page result | It only repeats numbers | Writes a simple conclusion | Indicates the limitation and the next step |
This rubric is an example. A real assignment should not be a secret way of unpaid work, it should be time-limited and candidate data should be anonymous. Apply the same task and the same criteria to all candidates.
Add a structured interview
US OPM structured interview guide explains the sequence of pre-written questions and assessment criteria. Give each candidate the same job situation: "The numbers from the two sources on the sales report don't match. What are your first three steps?" Evaluate the answer using the written criterion. Noting "looks like a good fit for our team" alone is not evidence of a decision.
Check the selection result later
Compare the initial rubric score with the observation at work 60–90 days after recruitment. Inconsistency may be a problem with the selection tool rather than the candidate. Did the assignment represent the real work of the role? Did the interviewers give the same score to the same evidence? The risk of discrimination of the selection criterion and the procedure for storing personal data should be checked separately in the local legal framework.
One page selection card
Write the three outcomes of the role, one ability for each outcome, one evidence for each ability, and a scoring criterion for each evidence. Have the interviewers complete their scores separately before making a decision, then discuss the differences. Don't be satisfied with "candidate A received 4 points" in the final decision; note which evidence justifies the score. Such a card also helps to track manual edits later.
Frequently asked questions
Remove the diploma from all vacancies? No. Keep in regulated positions and when there is a genuine job requirement; justify the necessity in other cases.
How long should a work sample be? Short enough to show essential skills; do not involve the candidate in the execution of a real project for free.
Can the interviewer freely ask questions? Although an additional question for clarification is possible, the basic criterion and comparison should apply equally to all.
Can the rubric change? Confirm before the start of the announcement and selection; do not silently change the criterion in the middle of the process.
For rubric and interview practice AİTM recruitment training baxın.